Cheap, Clean, and (Possibly) Crazy - Two Modern Amenities You Can Live Without

by Caleb Wojcik · 27 comments

This guest post is by Matt Madeiro, a modern day caveman who writes at Three New Leaves about his journey to live a healthier and simpler life by experimenting with the everyday life we’ve grown accustomed to. Take it away Matt!

2011 has been wild.

Call it a wild experiment in minimalism — a constant refinement of what I need to survive as I bumble my way across the USA and a never-ending series of questions about what I can cut to try and save some coin as I do.

The process has brought a few surprises. It’s also brought some perks. More than anything, though, it has offered a new perspective: do we really need all this stuff we have? Do we really need every modern amenity we’ve been raised to think we can’t live without?

The last seven months suggest not. The happy, healthy — and cheap! — life I’ve been living suggest there’s a lot of value in passing a critical eye over the commonplace, in taking a serious look at everything we spend our money on without a second thought. I’ll warn you now: these discoveries might seem a bit uncomfortable to start with, but sit tight and put on your experimental cap. You can pinch your nose, too. This time, at least, I’ll let it slide.

Ready for this? Let’s talk about the bathroom.

Let’s be clear: I smell wonderful. In the last six months of employing the two tricks below, I’ve never had a single complaint about odor, and likewise have even received multiple compliments on how smooth my skin is.

Do me a favor and don’t think too much about that last part. Let’s get started, shall we?

Smooth Skin Without Soap

It’s okay to wrinkle your nose.

It’s a sign of the times, I think, that soap has hit mandatory status. Call it a hint at our germ phobia that we obsess over being sparkly clean every hour of the day, scouring our skin every time we shower in the name of good personal hygiene.

Do we need soap, though? Do we need bottles upon bottles of pleasant-smelling goop? That colorful bar sitting in your shower might not normally raise red flags, but there’s an alternative perspective worth considering the next time you sling a whole bag of bars into your shopping cart.

Water is the ultimate cleanser.

That’s pretty obvious to some, but it’s a point worth framing in the context of your daily cleansing. Why, when a fair number of us spend our days indoors, do we rub and scrub like we’re covered in dirt? Why, when a simple rinse is more than enough to keep our skin clean, do we insist on throwing products into the mix?

Try a little experiment: for one week, skip out on soap. Run your fingers along your skin to make sure the water spreads around, but otherwise don’t bother to break out your usual bar or body wash. If you’re worried about a certain smell wafting out from your armpits, don’t fret — rub your fingers against said pit for ten or fifteen seconds and I think you’ll be pleasantly! surprised by the cleanliness that follows.

The end result? Smooth, clean skin without any need for chemicals. Given how much we shell out for body products over the course of our lives, I’d call that a win. Given too that the dry skin and occasional acne I dealt with have both vanished since skipping the soap, I’d say there are some pretty compelling reasons to experiment with a soap-free routine.

Shampoo Might Actually Be a Sham

Ever heard of “no-poo”?

Unfortunate title aside, the no-shampoo movement has gained quite a bit of steam over the last few years. A number of early adopters forwent the bottle for health reasons, citing concerns over ingredients like Sodium Lauryl Sulfate that come under fire seemingly every week. For the more economic-minded amongst us, however, the truth about conventional shampoo might be even easier to swallow: it isn’t necessary in any sense of the word. If you’re the type to throw down coin on fancy formulas, too, it can weight pretty heavily on the wallet.

Speaking from personal experience, my reliance on shampoo came with some pretty significant drawbacks. I’d wake up every morning with a head full of grease, necessitating daily shampoo bombing just to try and control the mess. I accepted that as normal for a time before starting to ask a simple question: what in the world did people do before shampoo? How in the world did we survive without it?

The answer? You’ve heard it before: water is the ultimate cleanser.

For the sake of clarity, though, let’s talk a bit about what shampoo does. When you squeeze it onto your scalp, shampoo strips your hair completely of its natural oils, often to the point where you need a conditioner just to reintroduce some moisture. As an occasional thing, this wouldn’t be too problematic, but your scalp does a funny thing when you consistently take away its natural oil: it adapts. It produces more. It produces much more oil than it should to try and compensate for the chemical cleansing, and it eventually starts doing do so on a daily basis in anticipation of further shampooing.

My daily dose of grease, in hindsight, wasn’t so surprising. I’d call it a natural response to my daily insistence on shampooing. The ultimate goal, here, is some semblance of normalcy: the ability to shampoo your hair only when the natural buildup of oil becomes too much, and the ability to clean it without throwing down a bunch of coins on some fancy product.

If you’re interested in trying no-poo, I invite you to check out my latest eBook, Roots, which discusses it in full. The process takes a few weeks to a few months, depending on how often you shampoo now, but there’s one trick you can employ while starting to space out your shampooing: baking soda. Buy a box for a buck, dump some into a cup, and mix it with water whenever you hop into the shower.

You’ll be pleasantly surprised when you rub that mixture into your hair: smooth, clean hair courtesy of a gentler cleaning than regular shampoo can offer. You’ll be extra surprised when you realize that a single box of baking soda can last for months, cutting down pretty significantly on how much you would normally spend for shampoo.

If you’re the daily shampoo type, much as I was, you’ll be in for a treat. Your hair’s natural oil will, in time, start building at a far more relaxed pace, necessitating a baking soda rinse once every four or five days instead of the usual daily dose. Keep your hair short enough and you might not need the baking soda at all, relying on water alone to keep your scalp happy and clean.

The Big Takeaway

Like I said: 2011 has been wild.

This is experimental stuff, admittedly, and no doubt a little off-putting to anyone otherwise comfortable with their cleansing routine. Skipping out on soap and shampoo for these last six months of travel just drove home, personally speaking, how easy it is to live without them, and how a little deviation from the norm can translate to money saved in the long term.

Why not give it a shot? Your wallet will thank you, which is by far reason enough to ignore the strange looks you might get from anyone in the loop on your new way to bathe.

You There! What Could You Live Without?

Why not do a little experimentation of your own? Take a moment and think about what modern amenity you could live without. Are there any unnecessary products in your life that you’ve grown overly attached to?

Caleb and I want to hear from you in the comments. What could you live without?

(If you’re reading these sparkly words in an email or through RSS, you can comment here.)

So, what would you give the boot?

Matt Madeiro writes at Three New Leaves about food, fitness, and technology, and how taking a stepback with each can make all the difference in the world. He is also the author of recently released Roots: Growing Back to the Basics of a Simple Life.

(image 1) (image 2)



{ 25 comments… read them below or add one }

The Fritter August 18, 2011 at 7:48 am

Think I may try it. Already went to no soap and switched to a dry skin shampoo. But since I cut my hair short I am thinking I can get by without it. Only minor issue. I live in a very warm climate, (the Florida Keys). A lot of sweat and humidity. Odor may become an issue. I have cut back on the amount of deodorant I use but not sure if it is a good idea to quit completely.
I will try the baking soda though. Sounds like a good idea. Thanks for the post.
The Fritter

Reply to this comment

Caleb Wojcik August 18, 2011 at 12:27 pm

It definitely depends on a trial for each person I think and seeing if it works for them. Thanks for your input Fritter!

Reply to this comment

The Fritter August 19, 2011 at 4:36 pm

So today I went without soap or shampoo for the first time. All my hair fell out and a Hazmat team showed up at my door wanting to know where the dead body was.

Reply to this comment

Ioana August 18, 2011 at 8:25 am

Or you could just not wash your hair every day. I never understood why Americans do that. Traditionally hair was washed once a week (Saturday, so one would be clean Sunday), now we might wash it every 5 days, but every day? That’s simply unnecessary. From what I know most women in Europe don’t do it and are perfectly fine.
Plus women can easily replace shampoo with egg yellows combined with whatever else their hair needs (my hair is dry so I use olive oil), then put some vinegar in the rinsing water to clean away any grease excess. Old fashioned beauty tricks are the best. :)

Reply to this comment

Caleb Wojcik August 18, 2011 at 12:28 pm

I’d never heard of using egg yellows or olive oil for cleaning hair Ioana. I’ll see what my wife thinks of that… ;)

Reply to this comment

Leah August 18, 2011 at 8:52 am

I agree that Americans are overly obsessed with cleanliness, but I’m training for a half marathon. I need to clean myself after those multi-mile runs before work!

Reply to this comment

Caleb Wojcik August 18, 2011 at 12:29 pm

After a workout I always want to shower and clean right away too Leah. :)

Reply to this comment

Daddy by Default August 18, 2011 at 12:21 pm

I don’t know about this one man. I’m not ready to give up the soap just yet, and even if I wanted to, I’m not sure my wife would speak to me anymore. I can think of at least one other thing she wouldn’t do with me too.

Now, if you stopped at just getting rid of conditioner and bath gel, I could get into that.

Reply to this comment

Caleb Wojcik August 18, 2011 at 12:33 pm

Thanks for the thoughts Craig. Required cleanliness levels definitely change when you get married…

I have always questioned conditioner too.

Reply to this comment

Bekka Scott August 18, 2011 at 1:08 pm

I had a feeling this would be a Matt Madeiro post!!!
There are so many things I’m living without now… And except for living without most fruits (pesticide allergy… And you’d be surprised what is actually Organic), it is amazing and absolutely worth it!

Reply to this comment

Caleb Wojcik August 18, 2011 at 1:11 pm

Fruits would be hard to give up for me too Bekka. :)

Reply to this comment

Catherine August 18, 2011 at 1:30 pm

As much as everyone tells me you can live without shampoo/conditioner, for someone who has long curly, tangle-prone hair, you can’t convince me that giving up shampoo and conditioner is worth it! Having tried this a couple of years ago, my 20 minute routine turned into a couple of hours a day to detangle it, and the pain wasn’t worth it! I’d be interested to know if the book deals with that problem!

Reply to this comment

Matt Madeiro August 18, 2011 at 1:58 pm

Hi, Catherine!

You got me. :) That’s my one reservation with this advice: I’m a dude who keeps my hair at a normal length, so it’s hard for me to say that going no-poo will work for every person under the sun.

That said, I’ll offer this: the book brings in the perspective of a female friend of mine (Tessa Zeng at Rethinking Style) who uses baking soda to work with her hair, but her advice may not fully cover what you’re looking for. I have read (anecdotal, admittedly) plenty of accounts from women of all hair types who have successfully skipped out on shampoo, so I’d still say it’s pretty doable for you.

Have you read/attempted the Curly Girl routine? It’s similar to no poo, though it encourages the use of natural conditioners so you can still manage curly hair. I’m happy to pull in other reports (and the stories mentioned above) if you’d like to read them, so just let me know. :)

Though I focus on the money side of things in the article, my personal reasons for forgoing shampoo have a lot to do with the chemicals it contains. If you can find a method that works for you (and doesn’t waste hours!), I’d still say no-poo is worth the shot.

Thanks for the comment!

Reply to this comment

Catherine August 21, 2011 at 1:47 am

Hi Matt,

Having read through the curly girl routine, that’s pretty much what I do anyway! I am on the hunt for an organic shampoo without all the chemicals, but haven’t found one that works yet! There are disadvantages to being in such a small country (New Zealand) on occasion. But the hunt will continue!

I might also try the baking soda wash just to see how it goes!

Catherine

Reply to this comment

matt August 18, 2011 at 6:34 pm

been with out shampoo for almost a year now with no problems. I use a tiny bit of non-soap cleanser (ShiKai) on my body with a pumice stone after workouts. Dreamy.

Reply to this comment

Caleb Wojcik August 26, 2011 at 9:30 am

I’ve never heard of ShiKai, I’ll check it out.

Reply to this comment

Annie August 18, 2011 at 7:42 pm

Hi!
I went no poo for months to try it. It really did save some money! I used baking soda and an occasional ACV rinse. I had some ups and downs at first, primarily because my psoriasis decided to act up but other than that it was enjoyable. I eventually went back to a mild shampoo “just because” but still use the baking soda on occasion because it actually made my hair softer and easier to handle.

I haven’t tried going without soap tho. A girl’s gotta have her luxuries! :D

Reply to this comment

Megan August 19, 2011 at 8:53 am

I have tried (probably not for long enough) the “no-poo” method with baking soda and vinegar rinse. My hair was softer, but I had to do the routine every day, and I’m a “shower every other day” person.

I have stopped using body wash and have switched to all-natural soaps. As long as I keep them out of the spray of the shower head, they last a really long time. I don’t clean my whole body every time (legs and arms I almost always skip) because I don’t do anything super strenuous.

I might have to give the no-shampoo thing another go, especially since the shampoo that I’ve used for years and have loved is now discontinued and I’m almost out of my last bottle, and I haven’t found a replacement that I like in the least.

Reply to this comment

Vic Magary August 19, 2011 at 2:00 pm

Very interesting, Matt. . . I’ll have to give the no soap thing a trial. I’m a little leery given the amount that I exercise, but what the hell I live alone.

Yesterday I got rid of my car. The same day I rolled into my new home of Austin I drove my trusty 2000 Jeep Cherokee to one of those huge auto malls and sold it. I also do not have internet in my new apartment, this forces me to make a list of the things I need to do online when I journey to a library or coffee shop and not get distracted when I’m writing in my apartment. Oh, I also do not carry a cell phone. I am a weird one now that I think about it. . . :)

Reply to this comment

AXY August 19, 2011 at 5:01 pm

As a girl I was pretty proud of myself when I went down to just soap and shampoo (no facial scrub, no shower gel, no shaving foam, etc), I thought “how minimalist am I?”. Well you’ve just gone and blown that out the water haven’t you Matt? ;0)

May give the baking soda thing a try, maybe. But the no soap thing is a step too far for me, I have two boys under three, I do get really dirty!

I love that when i thought I’d heard all the minimalist stuff you pop up with something like this though. :0)

Reply to this comment

Ashley @ Money Talks August 20, 2011 at 8:31 am

Ok, here is my time to admit that I have never washed my face with anything but water. When I was a teenager I tried the fancy face washes to try to get rid of acne and it never seemed to help so I just used water. That seeemed to keep them away best of all. And it does seem like any time I try any fancy soaps on my face I just break out, which is the opposite of what they advertise! I never really considered not using soap on the rest of my body.

Reply to this comment

Jill August 22, 2011 at 10:36 am

I have taken the interim step of only washing my hair once a week but my niece has been no-poo for over a year. You would never know the difference. She adds a little lemon juice to the baking soda once and rinses every now and then. I might have to try this, I spend a ton of money on hair products….

Reply to this comment

Caleb Wojcik August 24, 2011 at 12:34 pm

Thanks everyone for all the great comments. I loved reading these. :)

Reply to this comment

David Stokley August 26, 2011 at 8:28 am

I’ve actually been going without soap the past few days (somewhat by choice…been showering in the second bathroom and forgot to bring the soap, too lazy to go get it) and haven’t got any comments either way, nor have I felt different.

Reply to this comment

Craig August 29, 2011 at 10:27 pm

Hey Matt,

Neat article. I live in Bangkok and walk to the subway every day and walk outside a lot each day. It’s hot here. Hot and greasy and smoggy and dirty.

No soap is no option. But on days when I don’t leave the house, a rinse is more than enough.

CG

Reply to this comment

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. Or subscribe without commenting.

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: